Back to Blog
Implementation Guide

How to Design High-Impact A/B Tests

Updated December 2025
12 min read
TL;DR

High-impact tests: (1) Test big changes, not button colors, (2) Focus on high-traffic pages, (3) Have a clear hypothesis before starting, (4) Measure the metric that matters to your business. Most tests fail because they're too small to detect—go bold.

Design Principles

Test big changes

Small tweaks need huge sample sizes. Test dramatically different approaches.

One variable at a time

If you change multiple things, you won't know what worked.

Clear hypothesis

State what you expect to happen and why before running the test.

Focus on high-traffic pages

Test where you have enough visitors to reach significance.

Measure what matters

Track the metric that actually impacts your business.

Write a Good Hypothesis

A good hypothesis follows this format:

"If we [change], then [metric] will [improve/decrease] because [reason]."

Example: "If we add customer testimonials above the fold, then conversion rate will increase by 10% because social proof reduces purchase anxiety."

High-Impact Test Ideas

Value proposition

Test completely different headlines and messaging

Page layout

Radical layout changes, not just element tweaks

Pricing presentation

Different pricing tiers, anchoring, annual toggle

Social proof

Testimonials vs logos vs case studies vs none

Form design

Multi-step vs single, field count, layout

Low-Impact Tests to Avoid

  • Button color changes: Rarely significant, needs huge sample sizes
  • Minor copy tweaks: "Buy Now" vs "Purchase" won't move the needle
  • Low-traffic pages: You'll never reach statistical significance
  • Tests without hypotheses: Random changes without reasoning

Start Testing

Ready to run high-impact tests? ExperimentHQ makes it easy to test big changes with our visual editor.

Share this article

Ready to start A/B testing?

Free forever plan available. No credit card required.